If all goes to plan, the rewards will be delivered to the player's in-game gift box
This is in the 1.0.1 version, I can't check if this problem is also present in the 1.1.3 version (EDIT on this: since I just finished the story I updated to 1.1.3, and I can now confirm the problem's fixed there)
If you want tons of more MTG information or support then read all the other wonderful articles on the Draftsim blog, and use the Arena Tutor app to take your play to another level
GR Gold Rare Eldlich the Mad Golden Lord X LIGHT Level 10 [ ZombieFusionEffect ] ATK 3800 DEF 3500 1 "Eldlich" monster + 1 Level 5 or higher Zombie monster This card's name becomes "Eldlich the Golden Lord" while on the field
Sam is wielding his trusty frying pan (which would make a hilarious equipment if included in the deck), while Frodo looks absolutely heroic posing with his Elven blade Sting before him while not so subtly gripping the One Ring
He's a great and dynamic value engine